Central Newmarket Homes for Sale

Central Newmarket Homes for Sale

Welcome to Central Newmarket, a vibrant neighborhood nestled in the heart of Newmarket, Ontario. This charming community is known for its rich history, friendly atmosphere, and a perfect blend of urban convenience and suburban tranquility. With tree-lined streets, beautifully maintained parks, and a variety of local shops and eateries, Central Newmarket offers a delightful living experience for families, professionals, and retirees alike.

One of the standout features of Central Newmarket is its accessibility. Residents enjoy easy access to major highways, making commuting to Toronto and surrounding areas a breeze. Public transport options, including GO Transit, provide additional connectivity, ensuring that you’re never far from the excitement of the city while still enjoying the peace of suburban life.

The neighborhood boasts an array of amenities, including top-rated schools, recreational facilities, and picturesque walking trails along the Holland River. Central Newmarket is also home to the historic Main Street, where you can explore unique boutiques, cozy cafes, and local farmers' markets, fostering a strong sense of community.

For those looking to call Central Newmarket home, there’s an exciting selection of homes for sale. From charming heritage houses to modern condominiums, the real estate market here caters to diverse tastes and budgets. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or seeking a family home, you’ll find a welcoming abode that suits your lifestyle.

Discover the charm of Central Newmarket, where community spirit thrives and the perfect home awaits you!

Newest Central Newmarket Homes for Sale

440 Sandford Street, Newmarket
$989,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ N14110436 MLS
The first thing you notice walking up to 440 Sandford is how much work has been done. Roof, windows, siding, soffit, fascia and eavestrough all new in 2021; brick painted white; windows in black; landscaping established with trees planted; and a new garage door in 2026.The sellers carried the same standard inside: engineered hardwood on the main in 2024 and upstairs in 2025, basement and carpet in 2024, furnace in 2023, water softener in 2025, and a garage finished top to bottom. 4+1 bedrooms and 2.5 baths, with four well-proportioned bedrooms full of character. The back half of the 57 x 106 ft lot belongs to the south-facing saltwater pool. New pool equipment 2025, liner 2019, deck and fence 2020. The deck wraps the pool end to end, with a pool bar to one side and a covered dining area for long evenings. Move in this fall and get excited for the summer to enjoy the lifestyle of this backyard. The new Mulock Park is a very short walk away: 16 acres of trails and green space, a natural play area, the cafe in the historic Mulock House, and skating in the winter. Newmarket's Main Street is a 10- to 15-minutewalk for shops and restaurants, with everyday retail minutes away.

440 Sandford Street, Newmarket
103 Arden Avenue, Newmarket
$1,049,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ N14104770 MLS
Welcome to 103 Arden Avenue, a charming detached 2.5-storey Century Home situated on a 43' x 98' lot in Central Newmarket. Offering 2,479 sq. ft. above grade, this spacious home features 4 bedrooms, a covered front porch and a long private driveway. The versatile loft offers additional space ideal for a home office, playroom, den or bonus living area. Enjoy an updated kitchen featuring all new appliances, along with updated electrical completed with an ESA permit. A unique opportunity to own a character-filled home with modern updates in a convenient location. *Washer and dryer to be installed. Heat pump and A/C to be installed on the third floor.*

103 Arden Avenue, Newmarket
419 Millard Avenue, Newmarket
$465,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ N14103682 MLS
**Attention Investors, Renovators & Builders!** Opportunity to own a detached 2-storey home in the established Central Newmarket neighbourhood. Situated on a corner lot, this vacant property offers 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, an unfinished partial basement and a detached garage. Conveniently located near Historic Main Street, Fairy Lake, parks, schools, shopping, restaurants and local amenities. **Property is being sold strictly in "As-Is, Where-Is" condition** and requires substantial repairs and renovations, Not currently move-in ready. Ideal for experienced buyers prepared to undertake extensive improvements, subject to municipal approvals where applicable. Buyers are encouraged to conduct their own due diligence regarding property condition, repairs, permits and intended use. An opportunity to restore or reimagine this property in a mature Newmarket community.

419 Millard Avenue, Newmarket
65 Millard Avenue, Newmarket
$849,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ N14101144 MLS
Opportunity knocks in the heart of Newmarket. This 1955 detached bungalow sits on a 59-foot-wide lot and is set up as two self-contained units, ideal for owner-occupiers who want help with the mortgage, multi-generational families and investors alike. The upper level offers 2 bedrooms, with a large primary suite featuring a walk-in closet and ensuite bath, a kitchen remodelled in 2020, a spacious main bath, a rear sunroom addition and private laundry in a private lower level storage/utility space. The lower level unit has its own private entrance, 1 bedroom, updated bathroom, large above-grade windows and private laundry. The standout at this property is the large detached double-car garage (Tandem) with its own gas furnace, which makes for an ideal workshop, gym, or hobby space few neighbouring homes can match. A 200-amp main panel plus 100-amp subpanel, central air (condenser 2025) and a 2024 roof round out the updates. Set in a Major Transit Station Area, a short stroll to Yonge Street, Upper Canada Mall, Old Newmarket, Fairy Lake, schools, parks and the GO station. Walk to some of Newmarket's Fav events, like Summer Concert Series, Farmers market + much more. Lower level Tenants in place; showings by appointment with notice.

65 Millard Avenue, Newmarket
151 Thoms Crescent, Newmarket
$899,999
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ N14100154 MLS
Welcome to 151 Thoms Cres. Beautiful Well Kept Three Bedroom and three bath Home in The Heart of Newmarket, Situated on a Quiet Family Friendly Street. Enjoy Summers in This Great Size Backyard with A Large Entertainers Patio (2019). This property stands out from others on the street with its exceptional features, including central air conditioner, a furnace, and separate entrance with a kitchen for extra income. Upgraded 200 Amp Breaker and Copper wiring Throughout Home. Desirable Location. Parks, Transit and Fairy Lake. Very convenient. Centrally Located Close to Southlake Hospital, Upper Canada Mall-Costo, Walmart, HomeSense, Michaels, Winners, Canadian tire, The Home Depot, Silver city Newmarket cinemas, McDonald's Chapters, Schools, Groceries, And Quick Access to Highway 400 and 404, Yonge Street, Bathurst Street. You Will Enjoy Visiting Fairy Lakes Multiple Trails, Parkland and Historic Main Street in Downtown Newmarket Which Offers Plenty of Shops and Restaurants. Location!!!

151 Thoms Crescent, Newmarket
98 Don Mor Drive, Newmarket
$869,888
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ N14030554 MLS
Welcome To The Heart Of Central Newmarket! Nestled On A Premium, Beautifully Landscaped 88 X 137 Mature Lot, This Charming Raised-Bungalow Offers Over 2,000 Sq Ft Of Total Living Space. Located In A Quiet, Family-Friendly Neighbourhood, This Warm And Inviting Home Perfectly Blends Space, Privacy, And Everyday Convenience. A True Gem! Lovingly Maintained & Full Of Charm! Cherished By The Same Family For Many Years, This 2+2 Bedroom, 2-Bath Home Offers A Versatile, Functional Layout. Boasting A Light-Filled Open-Concept Living And Dining Area Perfect For Entertaining, Generously-Sized Bedrooms, And Abundant Natural Light Throughout, It Creates An Airy, Welcoming Feel On Every Level. Unbeatable Location & Convenience! Stroll To Yonge Street, Fairy Lake, Scenic Walking Trails, And Historic Main Street's Trendy Shops And Restaurants. Ideally Situated Near Schools, Transit, Southlake Hospital, Newmarket GO, And Upper Canada Mall. An Incredible Opportunity For First-Time Buyers, Savvy Investors, Or Anyone Looking For Their Next Home.

98 Don Mor Drive, Newmarket
79 Beswick Drive, Newmarket
$1,049,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ N14031742 MLS
Set on one of Central Newmarket's wider lots with 60 feet of frontage and mature trees 79 Beswick Drive has been renovated throughout and is ready to move into.The main floor is open concept. The kitchen anchors it, with quartz counters, new cabinetry, stainless appliances and a centre island that opens through to the living and dining rooms. A glassed-in sunroom entry gives the home a proper foyer.Upstairs: three bedrooms and two full bathrooms, including a primary with its own ensuite.The lower level is finished and fully self-contained second kitchen, full bathroom, bedroom, separate sitting area and its own laundry, with a separate entrance. Ready for extended family, or for income.Outside, a 24' x 16' deck overlooks a fully fenced rear yard with extensive landscaping. The attached double garage and private drive park six.Walk to Fairy Lake Park and the trail system. Minutes to schools, shopping, Southlake, the rec centre, GO transit and Highway 404.

79 Beswick Drive, Newmarket
315 Roywood Crescent, Newmarket
$1,249,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ N14028882 MLS
Four plus one bedroom backsplit on a pie shaped lot that widens to 63 ft at the rear. Approximately 2,180 sq ft of total finished living space, 1,621 above grade plus 560 finished in the lower level. Open concept main floor with bay window and centre island kitchen. Hardwood on the main, upper and ground levels, laminate in the basement, no carpet anywhere. Three bedrooms upstairs plus a fourth on the ground level beside the family room. The family room runs nearly 23 ft, with a three sided modern fireplace, pantry and walk-out to the backyard. Backyard rebuilt in 2022: inground pool with new liner, interlock throughout and two side walkways, retaining walls. Finished lower level adds a fifth bedroom, office, sitting area and 3 piece bath. Heat pump does the heating with the gas furnace as backup, and a Nest thermostat switches between them to keep fuel and heating costs down. Upstairs fully redone in 2026: flooring, bathroom, staircase and paint. Kitchen, powder room and fireplace 2023. Five parking spaces. 200 amp service with a garage receptacle for electric vehicle charging. Set on a quiet crescent in a mature, established neighbourhood, close to Fairy Lake and its walking trails, and to parks, schools, transit and shopping.

315 Roywood Crescent, Newmarket
400 Handley Crescent, Newmarket
$1,228,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ N14006288 MLS
Welcome to 400 Handley Cres, a professionally renovated and exceptionally well-maintained 3+1 bedroom, 4 washrooms family home nestled on a quiet crescent in Newmarket. Thoughtfully updated with quality finishes throughout, this move-in-ready residence offers a functional layout, inviting living spaces, and a true sense of pride of ownership. The beautifully planted and landscaped backyard provides a peaceful and private outdoor retreat, with picturesque garden views from the kitchen and dining area. Imagine enjoying your morning coffee or weekend breakfast surrounded by greenery or unwinding outdoors on a warm summer evening-a wonderful extension of the home's living space. The renovated basement (2025) offers additional versatile living space, complete with soundproof ceiling insulation and a separate laundry room. The layout also offers potential for a separate entrance, providing added flexibility for an in-law suite or extended family living. Notable Features & Improvements: Roof (2020); extensive renovations (2022) including furnace & ductwork, plumbing, sewer lines, hardwood flooring and appliances; sump pump with battery backup; basement renovation (2025); gutters & downspouts (2026); and engineered landscaping. EV Charger Plug in garage. A beautifully cared-for, thoughtfully improved home that's ready to be enjoyed inside and out.

400 Handley Crescent, Newmarket
150 Lorne Avenue, Newmarket
$1,999,900
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ N14004456 MLS
Welcome to the distinguished John S. Millard House-an exceptional heritage residence where historic character has been thoughtfully preserved & seamlessly blended w/ modern comfort & sophistication. Sought after location just steps to Newmarket's award winning downtown w/ shops, restaurants, bars, farmers market, Riverwalk Commons & trail system. Fully renovated, the home showcases soaring ceilings, extensive trim, wainscoting, crown moulding & hand-scraped hardwood flooring. The gourmet kitchen features stone counters, retro appliances, tall cabinetry w/glass inserts, custom backsplash, lighting & flooring, flowing into a sunken "Muskoka" room rich in wood detailing & warmed by a gas fireplace, overlooking the expansive cottage-like backyard oasis w/ coveted western exposure. Formal living & dining rooms offer a step back in time w/ soaring ceilings, traditional baseboards & refined trim. The impressive primary suite features a generous walk-in closet leading to a fully updated ensuite w/ modern glass shower, inviting soaker tub & 9' ceilings. The walk-out lower level provides a private in-law suite, ideal for extended family or guests. Outside, the exceptionally rare, deep lot creates a private summer oasis complete w/ sparkling in-ground pool & private gazebo-perfect for entertaining & family gatherings. Beyond the pool, the original barn has been transformed into an extraordinary private retreat, featuring a games room, additional bedroom & ensuite on the lower level and a spectacular upper-level recreation room w/ live-edge bar, extensive wood & beam detailing and multiple lookouts overlooking the pool. The barn also offers exciting potential to become an exquisite carriage house. A rear bunky/shed adds to the property's authentic north-country charm. An incredibly rare offering that combines heritage, elegance, thoughtful renovation & exceptional recreational spaces-truly a piece of Newmarket history-reimagined for modern living!

150 Lorne Avenue, Newmarket
431 Eagle Street, Newmarket
$779,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ N13868664 MLS
Step into the warmth and character of this charming century home, where timeless architectural details blend beautifully with today's modern conveniences. From the moment you enter the front foyer, you'll appreciate the rich hardwood floors, classic wood trim, and stunning staircase that showcase the home's enduring craftsmanship. The main floor living area is accented with wooden shelves flanking the main window overlooking the front porch; while a connected Dining space offers a formal space for entertaining. The kitchen features updated granite counters to modernize the space along with a separate pantry and a generous eat-in space. Step into the sunroom, insulated for 3 season use, also works well as a year round workout room. Two second floor bedrooms share a 4 piece bathroom featuring a timeless clawfoot tub. Separate garage gives you flexible space for a car or storage and workshop. Side entry to the home direct to the basement or kitchen for convenience. Incredible walkability location.

431 Eagle Street, Newmarket
296 Eagle Street, Newmarket
$1,645,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ N13860984 MLS
The Henry Johnson House, Circa 1891 - one of Newmarket's landmark century homes. Situated on a rare double lot measuring roughly 93' wide x 170' deep, held under two separate titles. With Buff Brick and a plaque out front, come experience the historical house and the 2004 addition that opened up the main level and added a spectacular 500 square foot primary suite with a generous walk in closet and 4 piece ensuite. The exquisite kitchen offers quartz countertops, gas cooktop, wall and speed oven/microwave, extensive cupboards and pantry that opens up to the charming family room. Relax and enjoy the beautiful gas fireplace then open the French doors to the expansive 800 square foot deck overlooking the park like backyard. Also on the main floor is a formal dinning room with California shutters, and office/den with built in lined cabinets. Mechanical notes: Furnace and air conditioning (2023), roof (2020), 200-amp service. The beautiful yard features mature trees, perennial gardens, and a depth of lot that is rare this close to Main Street, Fairy Lake and the TomTaylor Trail. A century of Newmarket history, with nothing left on your list.

296 Eagle Street, Newmarket
Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!